To the Original: How Claims, Units and Pictures Are Checked
Revised
Every claim on this site is meant to lead back to an original: the patent as issued, the statute as printed, the book as published. This page explains how far back each kind of claim goes, and what a page says when it cannot go all the way.
Four reading levels
Every source a page lists is tagged with one of four reading levels, and what the page says must fit the tag.
| Reading level | What was read | What the page may do with it |
|---|---|---|
| Full text | The whole text: a web page, a document with its text, a complete digital edition | Quote it and use its numbers |
| Scanned page | The page image of an old book, gazette or patent | The same, with the page number given; where the image and its text layer differ, the image decides |
| Editor's abstract | Only a later editor's summary, or a catalog description of an item | Say whose summary it is, and never present it as the statute or the original wording |
| Bibliographic record | Only a title and publication details | Say that the work exists and give its title, with no numbers and no conclusions |
A claim seen only in a search-result snippet, with the source itself unread, reaches none of these levels and is not stated as fact. The short answer and the opening paragraph rest on sources at the first two levels, or name whose account they repeat.
Patents
- A patent is read from the issued document published by the US patent office or from its page in the Official Gazette of the United States Patent Office. Patents from before the Gazette began are read from the Commissioner of Patents' annual reports, and some original drawings from the National Archives' patent case files.
- A patent's own dates, filed and granted, are reported as the patent's dates. They are not turned into the date of invention, and a patent is not taken as proof that the thing was made, sold, widely used or the first of its kind.
- Claims are quoted in the patent's own words. A count made from a drawing, such as how many letters a keyboard figure puts where they sit today, is published only after that figure has been reread from the page image.
- A drawing whose public-domain status cannot be shown in both the United States and the European Union is not reproduced. Its mechanism may be drawn afresh from the patent specification as a schematic, which is how Garrett Morgan's 1923 traffic-signal patent is handled.
Old laws and their numbers
- A statute's wording is read from the page image of a printed edition. The scan's text layer is used to find the page and is never quoted on its own.
- The session, the passing and the date a law took effect are kept apart. The act 27 Hen. 8 c. 6, which made each handful four inches when horses were measured, belongs to the session of 1535–36 and applied from 1 May 1537.
- When only an editor's summary of a law could be read, the page says so. The 1593 act that set a mile at eight furlongs is cited on this site through Owen Ruffhead's 1770 summary of it until the text of the act itself is found.
- A rule that carries no date is given none. The barleycorn rule for the inch, printed in Latin in Cay's 1758 edition of the statutes, has no year attached, and no page assigns one.
- Present-day values come from NIST: Handbook 44, Appendix C, for units such as the mile, the furlong and the hand, and Special Publication 811 for factors such as one horsepower equal to 745.6999 watts. Current British values come from legislation.gov.uk. Present definitions are quoted, not worked out.
- Chains of units are recalculated, for instance 8 furlongs of 40 rods of 16.5 feet giving 5,280 feet, or 150 pounds raised 220 feet a minute giving 33,000 foot-pounds a minute. Each diagram and table is drawn from those same numbers. Recalculating confirms the arithmetic; whether a number was read correctly rests on its source, which every row names.
The shoe-size calculator
The calculator on the shoe-size page follows one description, W. H. Dooley's A Manual of Shoemaking (1912). On that scale a child's size 1 is 4 inches long, each size adds a third of an inch (Dooley states the step for sizes 1 to 5; the calculator carries it through the whole scale), the length of one barleycorn under the old rule for the inch, and the adult sizes begin after child's 13 1/2. A foot length typed in centimeters or inches becomes a range of sizes using Dooley's allowance of 2 to 2 1/2 sizes over the foot, which he gives for men's shoes, with 1 inch taken as exactly 2.54 centimeters. Dooley wrote that these measurements “are not now absolute”, and the calculator repeats that it is a history of the numbers, not a fitting or buying guide.
Today's British and American starting points, American women's sizes, the Paris point and Mondopoint are named on the page as conventions and are not calculated, because no usable source defining them was found. With scripts turned off, the page still shows the scale diagram and a table of worked values made by the same rules.
Firsts, inventors and causes
- An earliest known record is the earliest record found so far. It is never rewritten as the date, place or person of invention.
- A claim that someone was first, or invented a thing, needs two sources that do not copy each other or rest on the same original. When sources disagree and the disagreement cannot be settled, the Origin card says the sources disagree and the rival claims stand side by side, as with the two accounts of who shaped the QWERTY keyboard's letter order.
- A trade's decline is put down to a cause only where a historian or a record from the period says so. Where the evidence shows two changes in the same years and nothing more, the page says they happened in the same years.
- When documents of one kind conflict, an original outweighs a museum catalog, a catalog outweighs a named secondary study, and a study outweighs a general reference work. Open-edit encyclopedias are not cited at all.
The good story and the paper trail
The good story column records where a popular version is told, so a story is never pinned on an unnamed crowd. The paper trail column gives only what the documents show, at the reading level marked. A job fossil, such as the crier's “Oyez”, is listed only with the present state of its trade (surviving, declining or gone) and the public-domain dictionary that supports the word's history.
Pictures
- License, version, creator and the credit a source asks for are copied from each picture's own file page, picture by picture; the good name of a collection proves nothing about a particular file.
- Public domain is claimed only with a stated basis: when the maker died and under which jurisdiction, or a formal public-domain statement from the holder. A publication date alone is not taken as proof that holds in every country, and an anonymous print from a periodical gives the year it first appeared.
- Scans tied to extra conditions, such as non-commercial terms or a distributor's own usage rules, are left out. When a museum's own catalog entry was out of reach, the credit records that the check was made at the file page instead.
- No picture with a child in it is used, and patent drawings, charts, schematics and pages of dense text never serve as card pictures.
- Diagrams are designed from a principle, a statute's numbers or a patent's written specification or claims. Tracing a protected drawing, a standard's figure or a catalog illustration would still be copying, so without a license such a thing is described in words.
- Every timeline, chain, ledger and comparison drawn as a figure is repeated as an HTML table or list with the same information.
- Generated illustrations are labeled Illustration and only set a scene. They never stand in for a document, for how an object was built or for anything that carries a scale.
Rechecks
The Still in use? field on every Origin card is rechecked once a year, together with the editions of the official definitions it quotes. Historical prices and wages with a date and a source are settled facts and are not updated, though their source must stay traceable. Every substantive change is dated and listed in Marked in the margin, and Shop counter sets out the limits of the site.