Skip to the page
Who Decided the InchNothing ordinary got that way by accident.

Shop Counter: About Who Decided the Inch

Empty a coat pocket onto a table: a door key, a button, the stub of a pencil. Each one has a size and a shape that somebody settled at some point, and the reason is almost never printed on the thing itself.

Who Decided the Inch looks for those reasons in the written record. A page takes one familiar thing, whether an object, a vanished job, an old unit or a toy, and sets the story usually told about it beside the documents that can still be read: patents, statutes, treatises, trade catalogs, prints and photographs of surviving objects. Where the two agree, the page says so; where the record runs out, the page says that too, and stops.

This page is named for a shop counter, the place where an object and its paperwork could lie side by side.

Four drawers

  • Objects: why the keyboard, the paper clip, the barber's pole, the traffic signal and the zipper have the shapes they do, read against their patents and period records.
  • Lost Trades: lamplighters, knocker-uppers, switchboard operators, town criers and ice harvesters, with what the work involved and how it faded, as far as the records show.
  • Old Measures: the inch, the mile and the furlong, horsepower, barleycorn shoe sizes and the hand used for horses, each value traced to the law or book that records it.
  • Playthings: the teddy bear, the yo-yo, the jigsaw puzzle and Friedrich Froebel's numbered gifts for the kindergarten.

Coins and banknotes, paper sizes, and the way the yard and the inch reached their present metric values fall outside the site's scope. For any unit, today's exact definition gets one line and a link to the official source.

Who the pages serve

The pages are written for anyone who has paused over one ordinary thing and wanted the long answer, such as who came up with the traffic signal or why a mile is 5,280 feet. Teachers, writers, riders and readers of kindergarten history will find origins they can cite. Nothing here is written for someone pricing an old toy, choosing shoes, planning a career or looking for an investment.

What falls outside the ledger

  • No valuations, prices for collectors, auction estimates or investment talk. Historical wages and catalog prices appear only with their date, place, currency and source, and are never converted into a present-day sum.
  • No authentication: the site does not judge whether a reader's own object is genuine, how old it is or what it is.
  • No shoe-fitting or foot-health advice. The shoe-size calculator follows one scale printed in 1912 and says plainly that it is not a fitting or buying guide.
  • No legal advice. Patents and statutes are read as history, and no page says what the law requires now or how an invention should be protected.
  • No reviews, product or brand recommendations, commission links or paid placements.
  • No advice on horses, on children's learning or on careers, and no predictions about which jobs will go next.
  • Nothing that sends a reader somewhere risky, such as onto frozen water, into a gas fitting, inside a signal or electrical cabinet, or near a horse.

Some arguments are left alone: present-day politics of measurement, rankings of countries or brands, and religious meaning. Religious objects, where they appear, are described as craft.

A point of view, and how far it goes

The tagline, Nothing ordinary got that way by accident., states a point of view; it is a figure of speech rather than a finding about history. In the site's view, “taken for granted” is the most expensive phrase in the language, because an object too dull to question has often come through an argument that nobody remembers. That view shapes which questions get asked. When the record shows a plain or accidental origin, the page reports a plain or accidental origin.

Five working positions follow from it. Each is a hypothesis tested again on every page, and a page says so when the documents do not bear it out.

  1. Lone-inventor stories get a second look. Pages look first at manufacturing cost, patents written to get around other patents, and compromises reached in committee. Where the documents point to a single inventor, the page names that person.
  2. A good story is checked, not presumed wrong. Every popular version is set beside the documents, and when they agree with it, the page says the story holds.
  3. A vanished trade is traced through costs and rules first. Wages, unit costs, laws and their enforcement, demand and changing habits are each examined. The answer may be several causes at once, or too little evidence to say.
  4. An odd unit may be doing a job. Imperial leftovers and counting in sixties have lasted, and the first question is what replacing them would cost; mocking old units is cheap. Each unit is still judged on its own record.
  5. A statute beats a legend, provided it is clear which layer was read. Old units are often defined in law, so the statute is sought first. When only a later editor's summary could be read, the page calls it a summary, and a rule that carries no year is given none.

What a page carries

Each article opens with an Origin card. Its first line is a short answer to the page's question; below it come the name, the category, the earliest known record, how firmly the origin can be attributed, the key document and whether the thing is still in use. A small note under the earliest record states that the earliest record found is not the date or place of invention.

When a popular version exists, a two-column box headed The good story / The paper trail gives the story on one side, with where it is told, and the documents on the other. The text of every article closes with Within arm's reach:, which points to something near the reader that still carries a trace of the origin and links to related pages.

The site has coined two terms of its own. Origin laundering is the way a plain, tangled origin gets replaced, retelling by retelling, by a story easier to repeat. A job fossil is a trace that a past trade or working technique left in the language.

How claims are checked

Each page starts from a primary document: a patent, a statute, a treatise, a catalog or the record of a surviving object. Every date, size, name and price is tied to a named source, and every source is tagged with the depth to which it was read, from the full text or a scanned page down to an editor's summary or a bare catalog entry. A claim that someone was first, or invented something, needs two independent sources. A patent counts as evidence of what was claimed and when, not of who made a thing popular. To the original sets out the method in full.

Pictures and colors

Old prints, paintings, catalog engravings, photographs of surviving objects and patent drawings appear as documents, each with a credit naming its creator and its license or public-domain basis. Diagrams and tables are plotted from figures given in the sources, and the data behind them can be downloaded.

Seven article cards at launch are generated illustrations. They set a scene, such as a street before dawn or a row of fasteners, and do nothing more. Each is labeled Illustration; none is presented as a historical photograph, a patent drawing, a period print or a document, and none serves as evidence of how a mechanism was built. No copyright is claimed in them. Credits and terms for every kind of picture are in Carbon copies.

The colors follow a copper object through its working life: the raw copper of a new casting, the verdigris it gathers after years in drawers and pockets, a little brass trim, the cream of patent paper, and ink.

Byline and errors

Who Decided the Inch is the only name in any byline. Mistakes can be reported by email to contact@whodecidedtheinch.com. No form exists, and no reply date is promised. A substantive correction is dated at the bottom of the changed page and entered in Marked in the margin. Ring the bell lists what helps a report, and Only the tally covers what a visit records.